Life After Divorce for Men – Depression Study

Coping With Separation and Divorce May Leave Guys Angry and Lonely

7 Comments
Join the Conversation
Angry About Divorce - Stanislav Vidic
Angry About Divorce - Stanislav Vidic
Men's lives change after divorce. Men have double the rate of depression that women do. Men can lose money, children, and social connection, resulting in loneliness.

Half of all marriages end in divorce and that number is even higher for second marriages. Well, so many articles, studies, and family members are concerned about how women are coping with divorce but, sometimes, it seems like divorced men are being ignored.

Divorce for Men

In reality, men usually have bigger emotional adjustment problems from divorce than women do. The causes are:

  • Loss of intimacy
  • Loss of social connection
  • Reduced finances

And, while men often complain about the money (spousal maintenance, child support, loss of assets), this is probably because it is easier for guys to talk about money than it is for them to talk about love and other emotions.

Well, no one should ignore the fact that divorce is hard on everyone. Women (and children) also take a big financial hit, lose their friends, and go through many of the same things that men do. However, if there are younger children in the family, divorced women will continue to have the company of their kids. While, often, the dads are left all alone.

Men's Divorce Anger

Most of the time, a wife will have been the spouse initiating the divorce. And, according to Kathleen O’Connell Corcoran, PhD, in the article "Psychological and Emotional Aspects of Divorce" on Mediate.com, “When a (person) has not initiated the divorce, they may feel” the following emotions:

  • Shock
  • Betrayal
  • Loss of control
  • Victimization
  • Decreased self-esteem
  • Insecurity
  • Anger
  • A desire to get even
  • The wish to reconcile

While all of these feelings are common, men should remember that it takes two to get a divorce. Don't blame everything on the wife. (And, wives, don't blame everything on the husband.) Also, just because these feelings of anger and sadness are common, a man should not act out his anger or desire to get even.

Men and Depression

While both men and women have a higher risk of depression after a divorce, a longitudinal study, in Canada, revealed that men have a much higher risk of post divorce depression than women do. The Canadian study followed couples after the dissolution of their marriages, as well as couples after the breakup of their common-law marriages (couples who were living together, but unmarried).

According to the May 22, 2007 article "Study: Marital Breakdown and Subsequent Depression", in The Daily of Canada, “Men aged 20 to 64 who had divorced or separated were six times more likely to report an episode of depression than were men who remained married.”

The Canadian study controlled for other variables, which are often factors during a divorce, and can contribute to depression, but are sometimes unrelated to divorce. These variables are:

  • Income
  • Social support
  • The presence of children
  • History of depression

After controlling for these variables, men were still 3.3 times more likely to be depressed after divorce than a married man was. Women were 2.2 times more likely to be depressed than their married sisters were.

Losing Custody

The research suggests that a man’s loss of contact with his children is one of the most stressful components of his life after divorce. Men are upset by the loss of custody and the change in parental responsibility.

Women and children suffer quite a lot in divorce, but men are the ones who might benefit the most from a divorce support group or from better family support. Many divorced men confide in their post divorce girlfriends, saying that they are angry, lonely, and depressed, but more needs to be done to reach out to divorced dads.

Any man who is not getting emotional support from his social network should consider forwarding this article to his family. Most parents and siblings do not understand how hard it is for a guy to go through a divorce.

Information from this article is not intended to be a substitute for advice from a lawyer, financial planner, therapist, or other professional. Please consult a lawyer or other professional for specific advice.

Find this interesting? Read also:

How to Write a Dating Profile for Men

Helping Children Cope With Divorce

Divorced Men Coping With Divorce Depression

Fathers' Rights and Joint Custody of Children

Fathers' Rights, Custody, and Move-away Issues

Resources:

Corcoran, Kathleen O’Connell, PhD. Mediate.com. Psychological and Emotional Aspects of Divorce, June, 1997 (accessed March 22, 2010).

Statistics Canada.Study: Marital Breakdown and Subsequent Depression, May 22, 2007 (accessed March 22, 2010).

Tina in the South of France, photo Raymond Gregoire

Christina Gregoire - Christina Gregoire writes about divorce, fashion, and baby boomers. Her forte is explaining complex ideas in simple language.

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 5+0?

Comments

Oct 5, 2010 7:09 AM
Guest :
Was helpfully.
Nov 25, 2010 2:29 PM
Guest :
I think this was a great article and i wish their was more help and understanding for the men that do go through this imrecently going through this and have found realy no help for me out their i feel it is a up hill battle finacialy and court wise everyone wants money from me from suport payment and lawyers but they also want me to miss work to sit in court alday to fight for joint custody of my girls when im a great father always have been so why dose a father have to fight for joint it should be mandatory 50/50 down the middle no court no missing work this im sure would help bring down the stress level in a man or lady and no suport payment s just a thought :)
May 15, 2011 6:04 AM
Guest :
I love my children very much, but the reality about it is the women most of the time know this, so in my case she uses this to crush me by claiming false accusations to place a restraining order against me, also instead of working with me to pay bills she has filed for child support... I have no choice but to shut down my feelings for my kids because the thought of them makes me break down. It's not that I don't care, it's just I must stay strong to keep my employment...
Oct 11, 2011 3:31 PM
Guest :
There is a real problem with the entire system & it has to do with "psychological framing". People in general do not seem to be able to state the politically incorrect truth. Shift your frame of reference from this "Golden Uterus Syndromed" single mother, back to a family dynamic. A good majority of women (18% BiPolar, 22% ADHD, Cluster-B Personality Disordered) are neither fit as parents or partners. The children would be better off with the Dads (the sane ones) plus day care. This would be better for the children psychologically. Just say it, MOST divorced women are psychologically disturbed. The system has been twisted to cater to them.
Oct 12, 2011 2:16 PM
Christina Gregoire :
Dear Psychological Framing,

I would not agree that all, or even most, divorced women are psychologically disturbed. I do know that, in my case, we had to split up my children (one child went with her father and one went to me), and her father was an excellent parent in most respects. This was my choice, not the courts decision and it was based on an issue of safety. I may have made the wrong choice, but there were no good choices.

However, and I'm not a trained psychiatrist, so take this next statement with a grain of salt: I have met divorced women who I think might have fit the profile you discuss. On the other hand, I have dated divorced men who might have fit the profile, as well.

I don't think that mothers are inherently better parents than some fathers. You cannot make generalities. You must take the issue of custody on a case by case basis. Unfortunately, custody is often based upon gender and upon the fact that some lawyers are better than others.

Often, there is no good answer when it comes to divorce. And, the person who gets the short end of the stick is the child.
Jan 18, 2012 6:35 PM
Guest :
Divorce laws are crap. Men are the victims of reverse discrimination and recrimination by the feminist movement. No wonder they feel depressed. DUH! As Shakespeare said Lets kill the lawyers and why dont we add the ex wives to.
Feb 7, 2012 8:43 PM
Guest :
One day I will learn about my actions (before its too late), and perhaps I will see the light at the end of the tunnel before its too late. I love my wife and child, I hope to never lose them. If I ever do, I wouldn't know what to do, I would be lost...
7 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement