Fathers' Rights, Custody, and Move Away Laws

Child Custody, Visitation Rights, Best Interest, and Relocation

20 Comments
Join the Conversation
Child Custody Rights - ali110
Child Custody Rights - ali110
Here are some issues concerning fathers' rights, custody, and mothers who want to move away. These are some things to ask an attorney about child custody and relocation.

With so many people relocating annually for new jobs or new lives, important questions about fathers’ rights, concerning custody and move-away issues, remain unresolved. Here is some information, about child custody and relocation, for dads to consider and discuss with their custody attorneys.

Relocation is not just a fathers’ rights issue, it’s a family rights issue.

Although there are instances where the father is the custodial parent and the mother is fighting the father’s relocation, most commonly, it is the other way around. For simplicity, it will be assumed that the mother is the parent contemplating relocation.

Child Custody Laws Vary By State

Each state has different laws about divorce and child custody, and these laws change over time. That is why it is so important for fathers to consult their own attorneys about their own specific custody cases. This article is an attempt to inform, not to give legal advice.

Child custody rights are complex and varied.

A good lawyer is needed to fight a mother’s relocation and to keep a father involved in his child’s life. Yet, no matter how unfair it seems, sometimes the current laws will not support a father’s right to see his own child regularly. Every situation is different.

Custody Rights

According to the article, “Family Law – Relocation with Children,” by attorney Maury D. Beaulier (2006), it is important to know the specific laws and procedures used to fight a relocation, and to follow the proper steps in order to retain visitation rights.

Here are some requirements, issues, and terminology commonly used in various states:

  • Notification: In some states, a mother must notify a father well in advance of her intended move. States that require notification have different rules about when a mother must notify the father. Sometimes a mother can move anywhere within state with no notification and some states say that a mother cannot move more than 150 miles without notification, and so on.
  • Objection: In states where notification is required, a father will often file an objection (to the relocation) or file a motion seeking to stop the mother from relocating.
  • Consent and Order: Some states require notification and (the father’s) consent to allow the move. In states which require consent, where both parents do not consent (agree) to the move, a mother might bring a motion seeking the court’s permission to move.
  • Sometimes, the mother's motion includes a request for a change of custody.

Best Interest of Child

What factors are taken into account when determining what is in the best interest of a child? Some states spell out exactly what should be taken into consideration, when making a decision about relocation, and some states don’t, but here are a few common areas of interest to the courts:

  • The child’s age
  • The relationship between father and child
  • A father’s involvement in his children’s lives
  • How a move might interfere with the father-child relationship
  • Other people in the child’s life, such as siblings or extended family
  • How the move might benefit or harm the child
  • The mother’s reason for relocation. (If moving for employment, could she get similar job nearby? Is her intent to harm the father’s rights and deny him access to his children?)
  • The impact upon the father (in time and money), to see his children
  • A mother’s failure to follow a court order

Preventing a Move

It is usually easier to stop a move from happening, than to reverse a relocation after the fact. It is important to act quickly. Fathers, who are still involved in divorce proceedings, should include provisions about relocation in their divorce documents.

These are just a few of the factors to think about before meeting with a custody attorney. It is not always possible for a father to stop a relocation, but finding a good divorce or custody lawyer may give a dad a chance.

Information from this article is not intended to be a substitute for advice from a lawyer, financial planner, therapist, or other professional. Please consult a lawyer or other professional for specific advice.

Find this interesting?

How to Write a Dating Profile for Men

Grants for Single Mothers to Pay Bills

Stepchildren & Biological Children's Rivalry

How to Help a Child Get Used to a New Neighborhood

Step Parent's Rights - A Stepfather's Role

Resources:

Beaulier, Maury D. Attorney at Law. "Custody: Relocating with Minor Children", 2006. hg.org.

Beaulier, Maury D. Attorney at Law. "Fighting Relocation with Children", 2006.

Tina in the South of France, photo Raymond Gregoire

Christina Gregoire - Christina Gregoire writes about divorce, fashion, and baby boomers. Her forte is explaining complex ideas in simple language.

rss
Advertisement
Leave a comment

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
Submit
What is 8+8?
20 Comments

Comments

Apr 9, 2010 12:32 PM
Guest :
It's obviously geared towards men, but doesn't address the issue of those men who would use a Motion to Modify instead of filing the state mandated Objection to Relocation. It also doesn't address those men who would use the same as leverage for diminishing their legal obligations to pay child support. The article is biased, at best. Perhaps a stern warning for those who would try to control their ex spouses by objecting to their relocations should be made, ey? What REALLY happened to the best interests of the children?
Jul 6, 2010 8:11 PM
Guest :
I think having a father in thier lives is definitely more important than any monetary value. Just like a woman, thinking about money only.
Jul 10, 2010 1:29 PM
Christina Gregoire :
Dear Guest,

You said:
"I think having a father in thier lives is definitely more important than any monetary value. Just like a woman, thinking about money only."

I say: I'm thinking about the children only! I am telling fathers how to keep their kids in their lives. You have a serious attitude problem.




Sep 13, 2010 4:01 PM
Guest :
So what about when the divorce decree states that the child can not move. Mom wants to move. She already took me back to court to change the relocation but the judge agreed that my daughter can not move. So what does my ex do...moves anyways. Now I have my daughter living with me, which is awesome! We still need to change some things like: I'm still paying child support! And she wants me to meet her half way. What do I do? I can't afford to keep going to court!
Dec 3, 2010 9:17 AM
Guest :
What about when dad moves away because of a woman and not work, family, etc?? What do the MOTHER'S do that what the father to STAY????
Dec 3, 2010 9:51 AM
Guest :
What about when dad moves away because of a woman and not work, family, etc?? What do the MOTHER'S do that what the father to STAY????
Dec 3, 2010 11:09 AM
Guest :
What about when dad moves away because of a woman and not work, family, etc?? What do the MOTHER'S do that what the father to STAY????
Dec 18, 2010 5:43 AM
Guest :
Ridiculous. Its a father-geared bias. Frankly the laws in this country are a ridiculous attempt to play Solomon. Where the custodial parent goes the children should go. Period.
Feb 16, 2011 5:21 PM
Guest :
I just want everyone to understand.. mine is not about money. How about when a controlling and abusive ex will not allow you to move back home to your family and keeps taking you to court making constant false allegations about you to try to take your children? Or will never allow you to move back home to be around your family.. and uses the courts to keep you under control and dictate what you can and can not do? Or takes you to court when you even want to move 10 minutes down the road? Got and answer for that?? Do you really think that I don't want a father in their life?? He takes their clothes and toys and knows exactly what he can get away with, without going to jail!! Got an answer for that!! But the courts took away my right to ever move and see my family again!! BECAUSE AN ABUSIVE MAN HAD MORE MONEY AND TOLD THEM HE WANTED TO BE A FATHER!! BUT TOLD ME TO MY FACE HE WILL RUIN MY LIFE AND MAKE SURE I NEVER MAKE IT!! And had a lawyer who has more pull in this town!! I am not even from NY and have no family here!! 2 months after I moved here, my life is over!! GOT AN ANSWER FOR THAT!! I have no life and no family and no rights as a human anymore!! Only control and HELL!! SO DON'T GET ON HERE AND TALK ABOUT SOMETHING YOU HAVE NO CLUE ABOUT!!
Feb 28, 2011 8:48 PM
Guest :
What about the father who uses the child as leverage to finalize a divorce after he abandoned his family in a small town? A town full of drugs and NO EMPLOYMENT therefore leaving mom to pay bills WITH child support? Ok, you shouldn't move for employment reasons but how about not wanting to be stuck living off of welfare? Is a woman then forced by the court to be stuck in a dying area in order to keep her children? Is it not a PERSON'S RIGHT to be able to make a life for their children? I'd never want my ex to be out of my son's life, however I have ALWAYS been my son's primary caregiver, his father won't lift a finger to assist in getting him things so it falls on my shoulders to do so. He also isn't too great about his visitation and will randomly NOT SHOW UP. I have been called to pick up my son 30 minutes away because he won't stop crying when he is with his father and my ex doesn't "want to deal with it." However, he can tell me when I can move? I find this to be appalling and ridiculous. It is not only my right as a citizen of the United States to be able to provide for my children, it's also my right to choose where I live. I will not allow anyone to tell me where I can and can not live. It's ludicrous to have to obtain "permission" from a man who not only abandoned his family and moved into a new home with a woman less than 2 weeks later, but also put ME into so much debt I can't even breathe without worrying I'll be charged.
Feb 28, 2011 8:51 PM
Guest :
What about the father who uses the child as leverage to finalize a divorce after he abandoned his family in a small town? A town full of drugs and NO EMPLOYMENT therefore leaving mom to pay bills WITH child support? Ok, you shouldn't move for employment reasons but how about not wanting to be stuck living off of welfare? Is a woman then forced by the court to be stuck in a dying area in order to keep her children? Is it not a PERSON'S RIGHT to be able to make a life for their children? I'd never want my ex to be out of my son's life, however I have ALWAYS been my son's primary caregiver, his father won't lift a finger to assist in getting him things so it falls on my shoulders to do so. He also isn't too great about his visitation and will randomly NOT SHOW UP. I have been called to pick up my son 30 minutes away because he won't stop crying when he is with his father and my ex doesn't "want to deal with it." However, he can tell me when I can move? I find this to be appalling and ridiculous. It is not only my right as a citizen of the United States to be able to provide for my children, it's also my right to choose where I live. I will not allow anyone to tell me where I can and can not live. It's ludicrous to have to obtain "permission" from a man who not only abandoned his family and moved into a new home with a woman less than 2 weeks later, but also put ME into so much debt I can't even breathe without worrying I'll be charged.
Mar 2, 2011 2:33 PM
Christina Gregoire :
Dear Small Town,

I don't know the exact details of your situation, and every state has different divorce laws, but I hope you would be allowed to move to a better town if it were for the good of your son. You didn't say where you lived but you should find a free legal aid lawyer. If you are on welfare or anything similar, where you have a case worker, ask her who you can talk to about moving.

I just picked Arizona at random. If you look up "free public lawyers" and your state, or "free legal aid" and your state, you will get some phone numbers. For example:

Arizona Coalition Against Domestic Violence (ACADV) Legal Advocacy Hotline, Statewide, AZ Phone Number: 800-799-SAFE (7223) TTY: 800-787-3224 Toll Free: 800.782.6400

It sounds like you are not over the abandonment, but I think that, sometimes, things happen for a reason. It may be a good thing that this jerk bailed before you had 4 kids with him. I know you are hurt right now. I can hear the pain in your writing.
Mar 2, 2011 2:41 PM
Christina Gregoire :
PS Even if you are not a victim of domestic violence, the volunteers who man the telephones that I listed should have a list of public resources. I just picked these numbers at random from one of the websites that showed up. These people, or someone in a similar organization, should have a "social worker" type of directory and they should be able to point you in the right direction for some kind of legal advice. (My guess, based upon your letter, is that you don't sound like you are ready to move right now, but you should consider getting legal advice about how to deal with your ex.)
Mar 29, 2011 1:34 PM
Guest :
its geared for men, my son has special needs we moved away from my family and closer to my spouses six months after we lived here and i was considered a resident he filed for divorce without any indication i got papers certified mail, then he moved 62 miles away and left me here to care for a special needs child, im 1000 miles away from my support system and he just got his 3rd DUI. he no longer has a license i need help with my son, so i have petitioned since he is here when convient for him and my son requires care 24 hrs i need a reliable backup and help. he doesnt see it that way, he sees it as i am taking his son away but i need help with him and he is not here, he does not attend doctor appts, therapist appts, i do it all by myself. so i have petitioned so that i can be closer to a support system to help with my special needs child, his family doesnt see if i need any help, they dont even know how to care for him. threatening temporary custody because my petition isnt fair...fair what about leaving, that wasnt fair.
Mar 30, 2011 10:16 AM
Guest :
Frustrated: after reading this I am relieved but also irritated on the relocation issue. Yes, there are some good dads out there even if it doesn't work between a couple. However, there are also bad father out there who will use power such as this to control the mother. I hail from VA, the lovely and ridiculous commonwealth state....In my situation I never married the father of my son, he was ordered to pay child support and is now 3 years behind, I did my best to work 2 jobs and take care of my only son....I had three years of college under my belt and decided I needed to finish to obtain a better job. Asking permission from a man who I refer to as "Dead Beat Dad" disgust me....I do believe all circumstances should be taken into consideration before laws become black and white! More and more mothers are being put under thumbs for the wrong reasons.
Sep 13, 2011 2:47 PM
Guest :
You know, I have been thru a tragic move-away with my younger brother a couple years ago--and it was the pathetic and insidious situation I have ever experienced. I wish it on no one-especially if you're a father--you will lose. I had heard about these kinds of tragic situations before and had read about them--but it still did not prepare me for what my brother had to go thru. And he is still going thru- along with the poor innocent childs pain of losing her beloved father. I will tell you, all these so called experts that are involved with the Family Legal System needs their heads examined and thrown in jail along with the very selfish mothers that are out there. And there are alot of them come to find out. Not to start and gender war but this is fact...The Family Legal System is corrupt, greedy,biased and incompetent! They are the ones that are destroying childrens futures with there parents-along with a very selfish parent that want's to move for no good reasons but for their benefit...But, the sad thing about this is what the attorneys tell you -what the evaluators tell you is totally different than what the law states...None of them do what is in the best interest of the child-it's the opposite!!! They ripped children away from very good fit parents all the time for no good reason or some inane reason. Just because a mother fell out of love with the father and has a lover-wants to take the child thousands of miles away to live with hi
because she thinks she will have a better life is no good reason to take a child away from it's father. This is down right egregious...Oh, and her other excuse was the father had an erratic work
schedule and could not fulfill the childs needs. Well, you know what people--fathers do have to work for a living to put food on the table and roof over their heads and etc. I guess, fathers that are Emergency Room Doctors, International Airline Pilots, Traveling Executives or Security Guards or ect. just should not have children-because if you are in a custody divorce situation you are going to lose--you're gone too much. Please, tell me what is wrong with this picture...........This is absolutely insane-but it happens everyday in the court system and some states are worse than others. NO they do not take into consideration what is in the best interest of the child. The children are really the ones that lose. These are good fit and loving fathers I am talking about and they do NOT deserve what they get in the henious and unjust Family Legal System. Just because a mother is a mother does NOT mean she is the better parent-children need their fathers and stop destroying that people-it is far too painful for the children and it last a life time...This is what you call Legal Kidnapping!!!!
Sep 13, 2011 3:27 PM
Guest :
To one of the guest comments--There are alot more selfish and bad mothers out there. And the Legal System is very biased against fathers--they get crucified in the court system. Actually, along with the childs life it destroys the innocent good father and most are. And I am a woman.
So, you better do your research on all this because you will not win--only in court!

Nobody should be allowed to take a child away from a good parent--that is criminal and certainly not in the childs best interest!!!
Oct 3, 2011 2:53 PM
Guest :
Because if so many malicious women trying to keep good men out of their children's lives.
It has become increasingly difficult for children to be protected from seriously disturbed fathers. The courts have seen too many innocent fathers denigrated my unstable mothers
to objectively see that sometimes there are unfit fathers.
RThe courts need to dig a little deeper to see insanity for what it is.
Oct 3, 2011 8:53 PM
Christina Gregoire :
Well, every situation is different. I know one father who spent everything he had to get custody of his daughter...the ex-wife's father was a judge.

I also know fathers who walked away and were never part of their kid's lives.

You have to take each case individually and it's difficult to make blanket statements. The only truism is that the kids are already hurt by the divorce and both parents should stop fighting each other so they can figure out the best way to give emotional support to their children.

Dec 26, 2011 11:57 AM
Guest :
What about a father who is moving away for a better job and leaving a 10 yr old child with her mother?
20 Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement